During the 2024 season, Simpson served as Alabama's primary backup quarterback to starter Jalen Milroe where he appeared in six games. Simpson completed 14-of-25 passes, which translates to a 56 CMP%, for 167 yards, as well as rushed for 44 yards and a touchdown on eight attempts.

Kalen DeBoer viewed Alabama football quarterback Ty Simpson as a leader before he was named the team's starter or a team captain.